Opinion: Alt-Cycling is (NOT) Dead

A recent podcast called No Wrong Turns made the rounds declaring that "alt-biking is dead", sorta tongue-in-cheek, sorta youtube click-baity title. We’ve been kicking the message around the office here at VO for the last week, and honestly, the whole premise misses the mark and completely ignores the inclusiveness and fun at the heart of the "alt-cycling" ethos.
A Mutual Understanding
Before I dive into the deep end, I want to be clear about what I believe the alt-cycling "scene" actually is. At its core, the bike is just the catalyst - the shared excuse that brings people together, gets us outside, and sparks conversation. It isn’t the main event.

Focusing too heavily on the hardware is a fundamental misunderstanding of what alt-cycling is all about. When we reduce the culture to a checklist of vintage steel frames, wide tires, or a specific dress code, we miss the entire point. Those things are just byproducts of riding for comfort and curiosity rather than pure performance. Ultimately, alt-cycling isn’t an aesthetic you can buy off a rack - it’s a state of mind.
When an Ethos Becomes a Uniform
When "alt-cycling" first gained traction as a label, it was a breath of fresh air. It was a way for someone who wasn't comfortable in the roadie or full-squish mtb crowd to have a sense of community other-than the mainstream.

It was a catch-all label against the rigid, hyper-competitive gatekeeping that dominated cycling for decades - the unwritten and sometimes written rules about sock height, shaved legs, carbon fiber, high-performance, and average speed. It was supposed to be an open door: ride whatever you have, wear whatever, and prioritize having a good time over chasing a podium.

Somewhere along the line, "alt" started getting defined by a very specific checklist: steel frames, friction shifters, front baskets, flat pedals, gravel paths, and cutoff shorts. And once an ethos hardens into a uniform, it stops being inclusive. If someone rolls up to a group ride in bibs and road shoes and is made to feel unwelcome because they don't look "alt" enough, we haven’t solved the gatekeeping problem - we’ve just changed the outfit. It’s the exact same elitism, just wearing flannel.
In my experience, someone who shows up to an "alt" cycling event with a Trek/Specialized/Pinarello/insert-performance-road-bike-brand-here is just as welcome as someone who rolls up with a vintage Stumpjumper.
True Inclusiveness Means Making Room for Everyone
If we’re talking about real inclusiveness, that also means looking at who gets pushed to the margins in traditional bike spaces. For decades, mainstream cycling culture - especially the competitive and "hardcore" sides of it - was largely built around one narrow demographic, leaving everyday riders feeling like afterthoughts or outsiders.

One of the best things to come out of the broader alt-cycling movement has been seeing underrepresented riders carve out their own rides, wrenching spaces, and communities. That progress doesn't happen because of a trendy frame bag or a specific tire tread - it happens when people intentionally build spaces where riders of all backgrounds feel welcomed, respected, and not talked down to at the trailhead or the shop counter. And I applaud anyone who is working to make that happen.
When we reduce alt-cycling to a gear checklist or declare it "dead" because a trend has become more popular, we completely erase the actual human part of it: making cycling feel like a place where everyone genuinely belongs.
Remove the Bike from the Equation
If you strip away the marketing trends and the aesthetic policing, the core of alt-cycling comes down to three things: acceptance, inclusiveness, and enjoyment.
Notice that none of those things are bolted to a fork blade or dangled from your saddlebag.

When you remove the bike from the equation, the hardware stops being a personality test and goes back to being what it’s supposed to be: a tool for the ride you want to have that day.
-
Want to clip in, put on Lycra, and hammer out 60 miles on an aero road bike? Awesome. That gear exists because it can be comfortable and supportive for fast riding.
-
Want to strap a basket to a 90s mountain bike and ride to the bakery in sneakers? Also awesome. Can I have a bite when you get back?
-
Love the simplicity of a fixed gear, the capability of a full-suspension trail bike, or the utility of a cargo rig? Go for it. I ain't stoppin you.
At Velo Orange, we certainly have our design preferences - we love bikes that are practical, comfortable, and easy to work on in your own garage with standard tools. Whether it’s a Chessie set up for gravel adventures, a Polyvalent loaded down with racks, or a Neutrino built for hopping city curbs - we design frames to be blank canvases. We care about making bikes that are fun to ride and simple to maintain, not dictating who gets to ride them or how you’re supposed to dress once you roll out the driveway.
The Only Rule That Matters
You can’t kill a mindset just because a word becomes more popular than before. "Alt-cycling" isn't dead because it was never tied to a trend in the first place.

The whole point of riding bikes, any bike, is the freedom, community, and joy it brings you. The specific setup doesn't matter. Just be yourself, make room for others on the road and trail, and don't be a jerk to the person riding next to you.
Happy Riding, whatever you're riding, and whatever you're wearing.
Thanks James! I definitely think that’s a part of it! I can appreciate how often I see old, often “obsolete” stuff still in use bc it’s still perfectly good!
Great post!
My only additional thought is that I believe the alt-cycling concept includes more than acceptance, inclusiveness, and enjoyment. I would posit that it also includes the elements of keeping bicycles simple and non-disposable and avoiding the expense associated with silly technology pushed down from the racing set.
Leave a comment